EngTree
Back to Roots
26
civil·Delivery Solved

Earthworks in winter — at what moisture content do you halt compaction on Class 1A fill?

Road scheme in the Pennines, arguing with the RE about acceptable compaction limits in wet weather. Where's the definitive reference — SHW, MCHW, or is it down to the RE's discretion?

#earthworks#compaction#SHW·CuriousTom Brookes · 5 days ago

1 answer from verified professionals

  • 19
    CEng MIMechEChris TaudevinAccepted answer AI-reviewedKI 82

    SHW Series 600 is the reference — specifically the Moisture Condition Value limits in the contract-specific Appendix 6/1. For Class 1A general granular fill you're typically halting when the MCV falls outside the stated band, but the RE holds discretion under SHW 612 for compaction trials. The practical answer: agree an end-product (air-voids / in-situ density) spec rather than a method spec for winter working — it gives you both a defensible line.

Post an answer

Verified professionals only (chartered, incorporated, or Master Trade). Your credential badge appears on every answer.

Verify & answer

This thread is a candidate for a permanent Knowledge Entry

A Curator can promote the accepted answer into a verified, attributed Entry — and the author earns a share of subscription revenue under the APAR Pathway. This is how Roots feeds the corpus.